Practice area
Sports law
For athletes, clubs and sports associations.
In brief
In sport, association rules apply alongside state law. Club and association sanctions are reviewable by the courts, but only to a limited extent: what is examined is the basis in the statutes, a fair procedure, the finding of facts and proportionality. The Federal Court of Justice has upheld arbitration agreements in favour of the CAS in principle, BGH, judgment of 7 June 2016, KZR 6/15. Anyone who fights or plays within the rules is as a rule not liable for an opponent's injuries.
Legal position as at
Sport has a legal order of its own. Association statutes, arbitration agreements and sports tribunals interfere deeply with careers, often faster than state courts and with their own rules on deadlines and evidence.
I advise athletes, clubs and associations, review contracts before they are signed and represent you in proceedings before association and sports tribunals. One focus is combat sports, where questions of liability and doping allegations carry particular weight.
Association sanctions and their judicial review
Club and association sanctions rest on the statutes, not on an act of parliament. State courts do not set them aside at will, but they examine four points: whether there is a valid basis in the statutes at all, whether the procedure was fair, whether the facts were established soundly and whether the sanction is proportionate to the breach.
The deadlines for the internal remedy are in the association's rules and are usually much shorter than state deadlines. Miss them and the case is often lost on formal grounds alone.
Arbitration tribunals and the CAS
Many federations require an arbitration agreement in favour of the Court of Arbitration for Sport before admitting an athlete to competition. The Federal Court of Justice has held such agreements valid in principle and saw no abuse of a dominant market position in them, BGH, judgment of 7 June 2016, KZR 6/15. The route to the state courts is thereby largely closed.
In practice this means: what you sign before you start determines who later decides about your career. Those documents belong on the table before signature, not only once a dispute arises.
Doping
Doping allegations run on two levels at once. Under sports law a ban and the stripping of titles threaten under the NADA Code; under criminal law the Anti-Doping Act may apply, which since 2015 also covers self-doping. Both procedures have their own deadlines and their own rules of evidence.
The first reaction is decisive. Anyone who comments on the substance of the matter without legal support commits themselves early, and that carries through both procedures.
Liability in competition
Anyone taking part in a fight or a game accepts the risk typical of the sport. If an opponent is injured by an action within the rules, or only slightly outside them, liability under section 823 BGB is as a rule excluded. The line is crossed where the action no longer has anything to do with the sport.
For clubs and organisers, duties of care also come into consideration, for instance regarding equipment, supervision and the appointment of referees. Those duties can only be limited by contract to a small extent.
How I support you
- Reviewing and negotiating athlete and coach contracts
- Transfers, playing permits and bans
- Proceedings before association and sports tribunals
- Doping allegations and NADA proceedings
- Liability for injuries in training and competition
- Advertising, social media and personality rights
Frequently asked questions
Can I challenge a sanction imposed by my association?
Yes. First through the internal appeal levels of the association, then, depending on its statutes, before an arbitral tribunal or a state court. The time limits are short and are set out in the association rules, not in statute.
Who is liable for an injury in competition?
Anyone who fights or plays within the rules is generally not liable, because participants accept the risk typical of the sport. It is different in the case of a serious breach of the rules. Organisers and clubs may additionally be liable for breaching their duty of care.
May my club tell me what to post on social media?
Within certain limits yes, for instance through contract clauses on sponsors and the interests of the club. Such clauses must, however, be measured against freedom of expression and the law on standard terms. Have the contract checked before you sign.
Do I have to sign an arbitration agreement in order to compete?
Many federations make admission conditional on it, and the Federal Court of Justice has upheld that in principle. Before you sign you should know which tribunal thereby becomes competent and what deadlines and costs that entails.
What should I do if a doping sample is positive?
First, sign nothing and say nothing about the substance of the matter. Check the deadlines for opening the B sample, they are short. Then we clarify the origin of the substance, the documentation of the sampling and possible therapeutic use exemptions.
Articles on this practice area
Doping im Kampfsport, welche rechtlichen Konsequenzen drohen?
Canelo Álvarez und Jon Jones gehören zu den erfolgreichsten und bekanntesten Kampfsportlern, deren Dopingfälle für Schlagzeilen sorgten.
Beitrag lesenHaftung und rechtliche Grenzen im Kampfsport
Boxen, Kickboxen, Mixed Martial Arts und andere Kampfsportarten zeichnen sich durch körperliche Härte aus. Wo verläuft die rechtliche Grenze?
Beitrag lesenDürfen Vereine ihren Sportlern vorschreiben, was sie auf Instagram posten?
Für Sportler ist Social Media unabdingbar geworden. Das wirft die Frage auf, wie weit Vorgaben des Vereins reichen dürfen.
Beitrag lesenLet us talk about your case
Describe your case briefly, ideally before you sign the next contract.